Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS)
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are manufactured chemicals used in industrial processes and products such as some firefighting foams and water-, grease-, or stain-resistant materials. Most people will know them as “forever chemicals.” Thousands of types of PFAS were used in a variety of manufacturing and products and persist in the environment. For a property owner or business, the first questions are which chemicals are involved, where they were found, and which requirements apply.
Different chemicals and different requirements
PFOA and PFOS are two of the best-known chemicals in the PFAS family. However, regulations addressing those substances do not necessarily apply to the rest. Federal drinking water standards, environmental cleanup laws, reporting requirements, product restrictions, and hazardous waste regulations each serve different purposes and have different scopes.
EPA has designated PFOA and PFOS, including their specified salts and structural isomers, as hazardous substances under CERCLA. That designation can trigger release reporting requirements and cleanup liability. It does not mean that every PFAS detection requires the same response or makes someone liable.
When reviewing a PFAS sampling report, environmental assessment, or agency demand, it is important to identify the specific PFAS compounds detected and determine which laws, regulations, or agency requirements apply. Regulatory standards and reporting thresholds can change, so older sampling results, environmental reports or compliance determinations may not reflect current requirements.
Where a business may encounter PFAS questions
Historical use of certain firefighting foams, manufacturing materials, industrial coatings, waste management practices, or disposal activities can raise questions about possible PFAS contamination. A property may also be affected by contamination that migrated from an off-site source. The property’s history, specific chemical uses, and potential pathways for releases matter more than its industry classification alone.
Older environmental reports likely did not include PFAS in their analytical testing. Their absence from a sampling report does not establish that a property is free of PFAS contamination. At the same time, evidence of historical PFAS use does not, by itself, establish that a release occurred or determine who may be legally responsible.
What PFAS sampling can establish
A PFAS sampling plan should identify the specific compounds to test, the environmental media (such as soil, groundwater, surface water, or waste), and the laboratory methods and detection limits. Sampling results must then be evaluated against the standards or screening levels that apply to the particular substance, environmental medium, and regulatory purpose.
A drinking water standard, for example, should not automatically be treated as the soil cleanup standard for a commercial or industrial property. Different regulatory programs use different criteria for different purposes. Environmental consultants and legal counsel should work together to determine what the sampling results establish, which regulatory requirements apply, and whether further investigation or corrective action is necessary.
For a California investigation, review any DTSC or Water Board order to determine its scope. The orders may specify which PFAS compounds must be tested, where to collect samples, and what reporting requirements apply. They may also require investigation of chemicals, environmental media, or areas that were not included in earlier assessments.
Transactions, contracts, and cleanup costs
Buyers and sellers of commercial or industrial property, as well as business operators, may need to evaluate possible PFAS issues before completing a transaction or assuming liability for a facility. Due diligence may include reviewing prior environmental investigations, historical chemical inventories and manufacturing processes, waste disposal records, insurance coverage, existing agency orders and any known or suspected off-site sources of contamination.
The threat of finding PFAS concerns can affect property values, financing, insurance, and the cost and timing of a transaction. Purchase agreements and other contracts should clearly address responsibility for additional investigation, reporting, cleanup costs, and any contamination found after closing. Buyers and sellers should also consider if they need indemnification provisions, escrow holdbacks, access agreements, or other financial protections. Addressing these issues before closing can help prevent disputes and unexpected environmental liabilities later.
Questions about PFAS
Does an older Phase I report rule out PFAS contamination?
No. A Phase I Environmental Site Assessment generally involves reviewing property records, historical uses, regulatory databases, and site conditions rather than collecting and analyzing environmental samples. Older Phase I reports may not have considered PFAS use or contamination as part of the investigation. Review the report’s scope, date, site history, and recommendations to determine whether additional PFAS investigation is warranted.
Does a detection automatically establish liability?
No. Detecting PFAS does not, by itself, establish legal responsibility or mandate a cleanup. Those questions depend on numerous factors, including the specific PFAS compound, its concentration, the affected media, the source and history of release, applicable laws, and who is connected to the property or release. A sampling result is an important starting point but it must be evaluated in its regulatory and legal context.
Sources and agency resources
PFAS identified in a report or agency request?
Discuss which requirements apply and what the findings mean for investigation, liability, and the transaction.
This information is educational, not legal advice or a legal opinion. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Requirements and available options depend on the facts and applicable law.