Phase II Environmental Site Assessment

A Phase II environmental site assessment (ESA) uses environmental sampling to investigate suspected contamination in soil, groundwater, soil vapor, or other materials. It often follows a concern identified in a Phase I environmental assessment but may also address other information suggesting a potential release of hazardous substances or petroleum products. What the investigation can establish depends on the locations sampled, the chemicals tested, and the purpose of the investigation.

Define the question before selecting sampling locations

A Phase II environmental site assessment may investigate a former aboveground or underground storage tank, dry cleaning operation, manufacturing area, sump, imported fill, or potential contamination migrating from a neighboring property. The environmental professional selects sampling locations, depths, chemicals, and methods based on the property’s history and the purpose of the investigation.

A few samples near one feature may answer a narrow question without defining contamination throughout the property. Before sampling begins, confirm whether the investigation aims to identify a release, evaluate exposure, delineate the extent of contamination, support waste classification, or satisfy an agency request. These goals may require different sampling locations, testing methods, and levels of investigation.

Arrange access before scheduling field work

Drilling and other sampling activities can disrupt operations, damage paving, or encounter underground utilities. Before field work begins, an access agreement should address where and when the consultant can work, who restores the property, how the parties share reports and sampling results, and who handles soil, groundwater, or other waste generated by the investigation.

Phase II ESA sampling can also produce information relevant to environmental disclosures, regulatory reporting, and property transaction rights. Evaluate those issues before the investigation begins rather than assuming the report can remain private or that unfavorable results can be ignored.

A purchase agreement may impose a short environmental investigation period. Allow enough time for property access, field work, laboratory analysis, interpretation of results, and any necessary follow-up investigation. Delays can affect a buyer’s ability to evaluate environmental conditions and exercise its rights before closing.

Interpret results in context

A detection of a chemical in soil, groundwater, indoor air, or soil vapor is not, by itself, a complete legal or regulatory conclusion. Evaluate the concentrations, potential exposure pathways, data quality, site conditions, and applicable regulatory screening levels and cleanup criteria. A screening-level exceedance may warrant further evaluation without automatically establishing the cleanup standard or proving a regulatory violation.

Phase II ESA findings may lead to additional sampling, a broader investigation, discussions with a regulatory agency, or cleanup planning. A single round of sampling may not establish the source or extent of contamination, whether contamination has migrated, or the possible costs of investigation and remediation.

What the results mean for the transaction

Phase II ESA results may affect the purchase price, financing, closing conditions, and responsibility for investigation or cleanup. A laboratory report stating that a contaminant was “not detected” does not mean that the entire property is “clean.” The result is limited by the sampling locations, analytical methods, and chemicals tested.

For brownfield redevelopment, compare the investigation results with the property’s intended use and any applicable agency requirements. Testing near an old underground storage tank, for example, may not answer questions about soil that will be excavated elsewhere. DTSC or a Regional Water Quality Control Board may require additional investigation or cleanup before approving a proposed use or redevelopment.

Questions about Phase II assessments

Is a Phase II Environmental Site Assessment required after every Phase I?

No. A Phase II environmental site assessment is not automatically required after every Phase I. The need for soil, groundwater, indoor air, or soil vapor sampling depends on the Phase I findings, property transaction requirements, and any regulatory agency direction.

Does a Phase II Environmental Site Assessment tell me the total cleanup cost?

Not necessarily. A limited Phase II investigation may identify contamination without defining its full extent or determining the appropriate cleanup method. Additional sampling, investigation, and evaluation of cleanup options may be needed before estimating remediation costs.

Sources and agency resources

Planning sampling or reviewing Phase II results?

Discuss access terms, reporting questions, transaction deadlines, and how the findings affect legal responsibility.

Discuss Your Matter

This information is educational, not legal advice or a legal opinion. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Requirements and available options depend on the facts and applicable law.

Scroll to Top